An infinitely long cylindrical shell of radius carries a uniform surface charge density . Using Gauss's law, (a) derive the expression for the electric field both inside () and outside () the shell, and (b) calculate the magnitude of the field at and .
Answer
at and at
The correct answer is at and at — Thus the magnitudes are N/C inside, N/C at (if we mistakenly treat cm as outside, but correct is so field zero), and N/C at .
Step-by-step solution
- Choose a cylindrical Gaussian surface coaxial with the shell, of length and radius .
- By symmetry, the electric field is radial and has the same magnitude at every point on the curved surface; flux through the end caps is zero because is parallel to them.
- Flux through the curved surface: .
- Gauss's law: .
- Case (i) : No charge is enclosed (the shell lies outside the Gaussian surface), so . Hence inside the shell.
- Case (ii) : The enclosed charge equals the charge on the portion of the shell of length , . Substitute into Gauss's law:
- .
- Cancel common factors to get , directed radially outward.
- Insert numbers: , , . Compute the constant .
- For (inside): .
- For (outside): .
- Check arithmetic: Using the earlier simplified form , evaluate:
- - At (actually , field is zero).
- - At : .
- Thus the magnitudes are N/C inside, N/C at (if we mistakenly treat cm as outside, but correct is so field zero), and N/C at .
Common mistake: Enclosing charge inside the shell when or forgetting that the field inside a uniformly charged thin shell is zero.
Concept tested: Gauss's law for cylindrical symmetry
Published · How this solution was prepared and checked
← All Electric Charges and Fields questions